(Sorry--this became a rant.) On the WIR (Women in Red) message board, there are many that look upon many socialist ideals (government run healthcare, in particular) as a horrible blight upon society and something to be avoided at all costs. They use the downfall of the Soviet Union as a reason to not to adopt some of their practices.
I can't see what's so wrong with it, though! We're a different country, it's a different time, and whatever we're doing--it's not working. To not even consider it as an option when things are SO bad in the U.S. is neglectful. I look at other countries, and while nothing's perfect--alot of it sounds so much better. While Sicko didn't highlight anything bad about other countries' healthcare systems, they also weren't complete LIES--in France, they DO get a part-time nanny after they have a child, a 35-hour work week, and 8 weeks of vacation--not to mention the virtually free healthcare. Sweden gets 18 months PAID maternity/paternity leave.
The other argument against socializing programs are the taxes that are associated with funding these programs. Not that I trust the U.S. government to be able to handle organizing these programs as efficiently to minimize the cost, but what exactly is so horrible about paying the government so you don't have to worry if you get sick or hurt?
The one thing that none of us as humans have a guarantee of is our health. Anything can happen at anytime. It is IMPOSSIBLE to save up enough money to guarantee that your financial situation doesn't suffer if you come down with, say, cancer. Basically, either way you are paying--either for the health insurance premiums, and for the tests and treatments when you get sick (for which there is no guarantee that that company will uphold their word), or to pay for it in taxes and cover all treatment. So, yeah--actually, I'd LIKE to pay for my healthcare in my taxes and take the profiteering OUT of the healthcare industry. And as you can see from my previous post, as an example, New Zealand citizens get paid-for healthcare, and I would pay LESS taxes than I do in the US. So at least on one case, that theory doesn't hold water. I have a feeling it would be worth it to pay for healthcare in taxes instead of having it tied to my job and not even guaranteed!
The most horrible thing that I've heard about in the US is when someone HAS health insurance, that person gets sick and thinks, "Oh, I don't have to worry about paying for it--I'm covered." And then, the health insurance company wriggles out of paying for it--WHICH THEY WERE PAID TO DO. This makes me soooo mad.
Lots of people would read this and say that if I hate America so much, I should leave...well, I am. And I'm so relieved and excited to experience another culture and way of doing things.
Oh! I just thought of something--given that my healthcare won't be tied to my job, I can try to negotiate for less hours in NZ (32 hours is mandatory to keep your healthcare coverage in the US) if I wanted!
One more question--if I were to get permanent residency in NZ and got healthcare, and then came back to the US for some reason, would I be covered with 'no gaps' for pre-existing conditions if I were to try to buy health insurance? How does that work?
3 comments:
I may go on a small rant too. Heres my take...
Capitalism preaches that capital belongs in the hand of the people and the people elect their leaders, that’s why they are called public servants. Communism (socialism to extreme) preaches that capital belongs to the all knowing and powerful state. It says that the people are too dumb to control their own money and should just show up for their work assignments and be told what then can or cannot have. In my view, the less socialistic we are the better.
The difference between those other countries and the US is that if you want the specific "benefits" you mentioned you need to find them yourself, you are not just entitled to them or given a hand out for "free". (Free in quotes because you pay in taxes) Find a job that provides a 35 hour work week, nanny during maternity leave, free healthcare, or a job that pays you enough money to buy all those things (and more) for yourself. Go into business for yourself and create those perks.
The reason France instituted a 35 hour work week was to help curb fairly large unemployment, attempting to force businesses to hire more people who work less. Most businesses said no thanks; now they just tell their employees to get 40 hours of work done in 35 hours. If you are paid hourly there's a smaller check. Sure it did help some, but government control over many things is always a very very bad thing.
Look at Medicare, social security, and other social programs here in the US. Yes they help a lot of people and are altruistic in nature, but the government usually messes things up due to this simple fact: Who will most likely make the right decision for you, your life, and your family? You?, or a bunch of people who need to make one decision that works for all 303,741,531 of us? Coyote Blog and many others ran some numbers and if THEY had control of their own earned money that went to social security -obtaining half of normal market returns - would have more than 5x more money then what is currently promised...Promised being the key word. CBS says SS will be broke in 2041, why? because the government usually screws things up, is inefficient, and can never make the right decision for every single person/family. The government also can create and change laws at will, and a lot of the "extra" money coming in from social security was used for other things, now it's going broke and there's no money to fix it.
Would you now want your healthcare provided by this same entity? They cannot get anything accomplished quickly because of the bogdowns with bureaucracy. Oh, and will your doctor still treat you with the same level of care when he/she is forced to take a massive salary cut because we all know that the healthcare industry is price gouging? Would you still go get 200k in school loan debt to become a professional in a field where profits and salaries are controlled by the government? I wouldn't... Same thing with drug manufacturers, will they pour on the research dollars to develop the latest drugs only to have their profits regulated?
I guess it comes down to whether or not you know yourself better than the government knows you and if you trust your decisions more than theirs. I would rather have the option of buying the benefits I want with the money I earned and being able to choose those benefits instead of having them handed to me by the government. Government's role should be very limited beyond the creation and protection of freedoms and the free markets. The best healthcare on Earth is very expensive and we should always have systems in place, even if they are fraught with problems, to help those who are truly in need, but to mandate such a tax and coverage on all citizens is one more step towards socialism and something I dont agree with.
I think most people who read/write/comment on finance blogs are a bit cold-hearted and very individualistic/capitalistic. I can see both sides of the issue but the argument that really bugs me is the claim of government bureaucracy/inefficiencies. The insurance industry has created massive inefficient bureaucracy and paperwork for doctor's offices and for individuals. I've spent hours researching and fighting claims as have many of my co-workers, friends and family. Many just give up because the paperwork is too daunting and pay even though insurance should had covered them.
What about the people who can't 'create' benefits for themselves due to illness or other factors? are we to leave them to suffer? As a citizen of a country, I think we are obligated somewhat to help our fellow citizens when they are down or having troubles--just as they would do for us. It's what ties us together as countrymen. I feel that some government handouts (and the funding of such handouts spread out over a country's population) is necessary.
I understand your point of view, spillingbuckets--I really do. But I also see alot of people (some of them in my family) who have their savings and lives wiped out by medical bills. That should never happen. Exorbitant profiting from treating (or even worse, NOT treating) illnesses should not happen either.
No one in either camp will be satisfied with the solution to this, whatever it is...but i read somewhere that the best compromise leaves both people angry.
Post a Comment