However, for future reference, option #1 is a go! My insurance will allow me to buy glasses in the US as long as my prescription is from an NZ approved doctor. This is what they wrote to me:
"Dear Ms Sense:
Prescription lenses and/or frames purchased overseas are able to be claimed under your glasses benefit provided they have been prescribed by a New Zealand registered optometrist.
The refund for this will be the actual cost up to $400 NZD per claims year. Your claims year is 1 March each year."
Hurray! I also remembered that Zenni Optical took my NZ prescription last year (actually, I don't think they even asked for it...), so I think that most places in the US will accept a NZ prescription (this is backed up by j., thanks for the comment!).
I decided that Option #2, just go for it!, was a really bad one. It would mean that I would have to pay nearly $400 out of pocket and save almost nothing this month, and I have some major purchases and money-bleeding coming up while I'm away in the US in August and September. I don't want to cut back when I'm on vacation. I want to be able to enjoy it, guilt-free. I felt trapped into paying a lot, though, since glasses are something I wear EVERY DAY. If I don't spend money on that, what should I spend my money on?!
So with these realizations/info, I have a whole new set of options. And I think I've found the perfect solution.
New Option #1: The glasses I bought last year from Zenni optical (love them!) with my old NZ prescription are sitting on my shelf here, in my room, as a back up pair. I can't really wear them, though--my NZ prescription last year (from Auckland Uni's Optometry school) is WRONG and basically unwearable. However, I tried the frames on and the frames are almost exactly what I was looking for. Sometimes it really is right under your nose (or on top of it)! Soooo...I can use my $400 allowance on new lenses for the Zenni frames and pay $0 out of pocket! And I could cancel my health insurance as soon as I'm reimbursed. Win and win! Fantastico!
If that fails, I can always just go to the US and get new frames/lenses. I would have $280 USD to use towards this. I think that is enough (it is plenty for Zenni Optical, that is for SURE).
I'm so glad I found an acceptable resolution to this budget problem. I was really dreading paying hundreds of dollars for glasses, but at the same time, I knew I'd have them for a long time, so I was justifying the cost to myself.
Whew. This is when I'm glad I am so anal. I think I'm saving myself quite a chunk of money by being so tenacious with this. I'm a budget pit bull!

