Showing posts with label fallout. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fallout. Show all posts

Sunday, June 20, 2010

Waiting for the Other Shoe

A few months back, I wrote about The Flood in our apartment.  It was biblical in proportion, it was wet, and it was definitely worthy of those two capital letters.  I also said that I notified our landlord about said Flood via phone call very soon after I came home and was greeted by water pouring down the stairs up to our apartment.  I'd say that I notified her within 10 minutes of that greeting, actually.  Upon some probing questions regarding the dimensions of The Flood, she told us good luck, and said that all we could do was sop up the mess as much as possible, borrow a dehumidifier, and try to squeegee the wet into the tiled floor in the kitchen and bathroom (they both have drains in the floor...I presume for these very occasions).  Then when I told her that I was pretty sure that it had penetrated to the apartment below us and that she may be getting a phone call from them about this, I could hear her shrug and say that she wasn't going to tell them anything, and that they could deal with it on their own (she doesn't like them).  Meanwhile, we did everything she suggested and more:  squeegeed the floor, borrowed a few dehumidifiers, sopped up the wet, rented a wet-vac, and sprinkled baking soda and vinegar on the carpet when it began to smell.  (The carpet is now perfectly clean (cleaner than it was before The Flood, thanks to the wet-vac!), and doesn't smell at all.)

Fast forward a month and a half later.  The apartment below us is being prepped for renting.  A lady in charge of the corporation that deals with the communal portions of our apartment building, and renting out the apartment below us, knocks on our door and asks if we have had any sort of water damage.  Roommate, annoyed that she is bothering us (landlord has given them STRICT instructions to ONLY deal with her, and to NEVER bother us), shoo's her out.

A few weeks after that, my landlord contacts me and tells me that the lady has reported three ceiling panels and a light fixture that needs to be replaced due to water damage.  Our landlord says that this damage coincides with the date of the flood and that she has admitted liability and is waiting for their repair estimate.

OK.  Now I'm not sure what to do.  On the one hand, our landlord hasn't said that we are totally responsible for the cost of the damages.  On the other, I notified her within a few hours of The Flood.  Wasn't the responsibility then passed on to her to notify the building maintenance people (who also are the landlords of the apartment downstairs)?  I think the damage could have been minimalized if she had taken immediate action, like we did in notifying her.

However, I'm afraid that the responsibility of the entire cost of The Flood will be placed on me and my roommate's shoulders, er, bank accounts.  And because my landlord hasn't explicitly said so, I'm afraid to ask, for fear that she thinks I'm volunteering to pay.  I think that The Flood, while entirely my roommate's doing, was a mistake that either I OR she could have made very easily--it's what I know she would do for me if circumstances were reversed.  Therefore, I'm willing to accept responsibility for half of the cost--I wouldn't make her pay the whole thing by herself.   The most fair way to do this would be for my landlord to pay for half, and for my roommate and I to pay the other half.  Yes?  No?  Thoughts?

p.s.  NO IDEA how homeowner's insurance works in NZ, or in this case.  Any advice would be welcome.  Do you think damages caused by your tenants to other apartments are covered in NZ homeowner's insurance?  Or is it entirely your tenants' responsibility?  How much does a ceiling panel cost, anyway?