The situation with the roommate continues...
I feel guilty about something, but don't know if I should offer to pay for my mistake or not.
Ex roommate left some of her stuff in my apartment in mid-December, saying that she'd be back in a few days to collect it. I agreed to this.
A few days later, she says she is coming by to grab it. She still has keys, so I say, sure, fine, come on in. New roommate is using some of her stuff (a lamp) until she comes to collect it. She doesn't show. Repeat of this a few days later.
I ask for the keys back, because my key, the original, is too dull to make another working copy, and the set that new roommate is using is tricky--takes about 3 minutes to open the door, if they work at all. It takes her another week to return that set of keys, even though I say it is urgent.
Old roommate sets several more appointments to come by, we make concessions, arrangements to be home at the appointed times, and never shows. This happens maybe 3 times since she returned her keys.
Fast forward 2 weeks after she gets her bond back. I have a bunch of people coming over to my apartment to stay. I don't want them to have to look or deal with her stuff. I facebook her, saying that if she does not collect her stuff in 5 days' time, I'm putting the biggest thing and eyesore that there is just no room for anymore (a broken TV) out on the curb. Last time we talked, facebook was her preferred method of communication. She says my emails to her about bills weren't getting through, and she runs out of credit on her phone all of the time and changes numbers so I am never sure of her current number. At this point, I'm sure she'll never be back because she has received her bond and has had zero communication with me except about money, her bond. If she had bothered to keep in contact with me (I have facebooked and texted several times to say merry christmas, happy new year, how are you?, no answer) or offer thanks for holding onto her stuff or kept any of her appointments without me nagging her 12 times, I would not have done what I did next.
Five days later, my friends are arriving in town, and I have not heard from her. I set the offending TV on the curb. It disappears.
Today, 6 days after that, she texts out of the blue to say that she is coming over to collect her stuff. I make arrangements for someone to be home. She collects her lamp and leaves the rest of it. She notices that the broken tv is gone.
She calls me, and I tell her what happened. She gets angry and says that I should have emailed, called, texted, etc. instead of facebooking, and I am to pay for the TV, as she has sold the broken TV to someone. I am friends with her on facebook. She has been on there nearly every day and has not responded to my message.
Feeling like I should have done more to contact her, I offer the (working) TV in the garage as a replacement. She refuses it.
So. Do I pay? I don't even know how much she sold it for, but once upon a time we (collectively, she and I) paid $50 for it. A major part of me does not want to do this because of all of the past drama, but what is your vote? I am obviously beyond seeing this rationally and can only see my side.
[ETA: OMG! She wants $70 for a broken TV. She is totally crazy.]