Showing posts with label accidents. Show all posts
Showing posts with label accidents. Show all posts

Friday, April 17, 2009

Would You Ever Refuse Money?

Well-heeled's post caught my eye--she refers to another blog author who refuses to take unemployment benefits because she doesn't want a handout and doesn't need the money--she has savings and her husband's income to live off of. This post isn't about that controversy (people are getting pretty angry because she apparently sounds elitist); this post is about what memories and feelings that situation brought up for me.

When I was in college, in my fourth and final year, I was walking across the street with some groceries in hand. I had to park my car pretty far away and down a huge hill from my dorm, so I was really dragging and tired. It was early evening, still light out, but at the end of the workday for most people. Traffic was horrible. I had to cross a single right turn lane and then cross a major road to get to the stairs that would take me to my dorm. The guy in the car in the right turn lane was looking left in order to guage gaps in the traffic; I was looking at him before I walked into the crosswalk from his right. I thought we made eye contact, and I thought I saw him give me a little wave, so I started walking in front of his car.

The next thing I knew, I was watching the chrome bumper of his car inch forward towards me in slow-motion. I couldn't react; the car hit me just above my left knee. My groceries went flying, I went flying, I did a somersault over the guy's hood and one of my Birkenstocks flew all the way into the major highway that the guy was trying to merge into! I honestly don't remember much of the accident. It happened SO FAST!

As I picked myself off of the ground, I noticed that all of my canned groceries were rolling all over the road, my shoe was missing, and I was MORTIFIED. There were a few people on the other side of the road that I was trying to cross to, and I knew some of them! Everyone started shouting and running over to help me, and the guy in the car just looked at me, completely dumb-founded.

I wanted to be on my way; I had an exam and an essay due the next day and had a lot of work to do. I also had a semi-formal to attend the next evening, and wanted to get my dress/accessories together. However, the guy driving the car eventually got out and talked to me. He had a Scottish accent and was really, really cute--I think that just made my embarrassment worse. The cops came, got my statement, and filled out a police report--I still have it somewhere! The guy driving the car wouldn't hear of me not going to get checked out, so I let him drive me to the hospital. I made sure my friend and the cops knew who I was with...

I ended up waiting in the hospital ER for about 5 hours with the scottish guy. Even more embarrassingly, I ran into more people I knew in the waiting room. It was so mortifying to explain, over and over, that I was hit by a CAR. So, so lame. (To this day, my college friends do this HILARIOUS exaggerated rendition of me getting hit; in it, i'm eating mcdonald's french fries, and scream like a crazy person and chuck my shoe across the road in a frenzy as I fall down. To no avail, I keep explaining that I WASN'T EATING FRENCH FRIES. or screaming, for that matter...)

Eventually, the doctors checked me out and concluded that I'd be sore and bruised, but I was ok. The next day dawned, and I had humongous bruises on my left thigh, hip, shoulders, scrapes on my elbows (everywhere that I'd landed on during my tumble over the guy's hood and eventually to the ground). The guy couldn't have been going more than about 6 mph, but I was totally wrecked, could barely walk. I can't imagine what would have happened at a speed higher than that!

I got out of my exam by explaining what had happened.

Unfortunately, my semi-formal plans were messed up. My best friend and I had been taking swing dance classes, and in the classes, he threw me in the air, twisted me around on the floor, helped me do flips, etc--it was SO much fun. The semi-formal was where we planned on debuting our new dance skillz. Wasn't happening...I could barely walk. The bruises kept me from doing any hip bumps or whatever, too. We ended up just hanging out on the dance floor and drinking all night instead.

My bruises and my ego eventually healed, and I graduated and headed home for the summer break. About halfway through the summer, I received a phone call from the scottish guy's car insurance company. They asked me what I wanted in compensation for the accident. I told them that I just wanted my ER bills paid for. Flabbergasted, the insurance rep said, 'and what else? is there anything we can do?' I stumbled, not knowing what to say. I could ask for MORE??

I should have handed the phone over to my mom or dad to handle it, but I didn't.

The rep then said that they could offer me $500 to make up for the accident, and that I should take my friends out for dinner with it. I said ok to that.

However, I felt really guilty. After all, I didn't do anything to earn the money--up until this point, I earned about $6.50 an hour selling shoes or sunglasses, or working for my dad's plumbing business. So $500 in one phone call was A LOT to me (still is!).

I used the money to help fund my flight out to grad school later that summer.

Looking back, I wonder how much more I could have gotten from them? What if I demanded thousands of dollars? Would they have paid up? What was their limit?? If they offered me $500 and thought they were getting deal, I wonder how much more could I have gotten? Enough to pay off my student loans at the time (~$3000)?? Free car insurance for life? I feel bad just thinking that...it seems opportunistic.

After I got off the phone, I explained to my mom that I didn't want to punish the guy that hit me--he had been really nice to me, called me multiple times to check up on me (to my mortification), and stayed with me the whole time I was in the waiting room. he didn't mean to do it; I put myself in his position, and hoped that if I ever hit anyone by accident, they would be nice and not demand money from me, either. I also didn't want to be like one of those people that sued McDonald's for the hot coffee--I didn't want to get something for nothing. (DUDES, i'm not being paid by MickeyD's for this post, I SWEAR.)

My mom then explained how it REALLY worked--no doubt the guy's rates skyrocketed after the accident, no matter how little I took from the insurance co. That $500 was probably his deductible! At most, I probably got that insurance rep a good mark on their performance review, and slightly boosted the stockholder's earnings that quarter.

However, even though I'm certain that I could have gotten more money out of the company without further punishing the scottish guy, I'm glad I didn't. I really didn't feel that I deserved money for it--no major damage was done! I was fine! It was my own stupid fault for walking into the middle of the road!

I'm a huge proponent of personal responsibility. Part of that accident was my fault, and I own up to it, even though I was in a crosswalk and legally had right-of-way.

This whole situation is not to say that other people shouldn't feel like they should get money for an accident that happens to them--these are purely my feelings about what happened to me.

So, what say you--have you had a similar experience? Would you have asked for more $?