Thursday, June 22, 2023

Shopping Around for Internet + Electricity in NZ

As part of my detailed budget review, I went over what I'm paying for internet and electricity. It is one of the only pseudo-subscription services that I receive and could possibly negotiate lower. 

It turns out that this process is a *HUGE* headache. They do NOT make it easy to compare plans and prices. 

Current Status

I'm currently with Contact Energy, on an open term Broadband bundle where my electric plan is Standard Economy User and my Broadband plan is $70/month. It was a special online deal that I received when I signed up in a tizzy when my last flatmate announced at the very last minute that she had cut off our internet and electricity several weeks before her move out date (still not sure why she did this????). I had to scramble to find a new plan that covered both electricity and internet in a few days so that my work-from-home schedule was not interrupted. An open term electricity + internet bundle plan was the easiest solution because I did not have time to price compare.


Current Electricity Prices

Fixed daily electricity charges: $1.987/day; $57.62 in my last bill

All Day Economy charge in cents per kWh: 18.8 (total based on usage); $78.40 in my last bill

Electricity Authority Levy in cents per kWh: 0.14 (total based on usage); 0.58 in my last bill

GST on all of the above: 15%

Last month my flatmate and I used 417 kWh and it cost $157.09 (including GST). This will undoubtedly go up as we use more electricity in the winter to power our water heater more and the heaters in our rooms at night (and sometimes during the day). 

This sort of usage qualifies us for "Low User" status, but we currently are not on a Low Usage plan, for whatever reason.

I do not know what a normal winter month for my flatmate and I will look like yet as I don't have that data available.


Other Considerations

Switching companies

Contact has terrible customer service ratings, so switching may be ideal just to ensure I'm with a better company. However, I don't want to deal with the hassle of switching unless some good savings are guaranteed.

Contract Terms 

I'm going to stay on open term (no 24 month contracts for me!) because I have no idea if I'm staying in NZ post-PhD. It is likely that I stay, and while I'm in NZ, I'd like to stay in my current apartment if I'm living in Auckland, however, I just can't predict the future and what it will bring. I need flexibility for now. My rental contract is also periodic (not annual) now, so this also makes sense in that regard.

Broadband Bundles

Our current prices are as follows:

Unlimited fibre broadband (at ~300 Mbps/100 Mbps speeds): $70/mo (including GST) with an online deal if I bundle it with electricity. $70/mo is smack dab in the mid-range of normal for NZ, based on my research into fibre broadband prices. There are options for faster fibre broadband out there but I'm pretty happy with what I receive currently, so I feel no need to lifestyle inflate at this time.

Speedtest.net results for my current internet connection (200 Mbps download; 96 Mbps upload):


Summary of What I'm Looking For

I'm looking to keep the open term status of my contract and mid-range or lower fibre broadband prices while also lowering my electricity costs.

 

Comparing Prices

Using NZ Compare, Contact Energy's website, and PowerSwitch, I've found the following power+internet open term bundles to compare: 

  • Contact Energy. The easiest option is to stay at Contact Energy. To qualify for their broadband service, I would need to receive electricity from Contact. I qualify for several of their other electricity plans because I apparently have a Smart Meter (?). In that case, I could switch to one of these other plans:

    • Low User: This has a lower fixed daily price but higher charge per kWh.
      Fixed daily charge: 0.90/day;
      Variable charge: 22.6 cents per kWh
      Broadband price may increase to $75/mo. (?)
      Under this plan, my last bill would have been $139.06 (including GST) as compared to $157.09.
    • Good Nights: Free electricity from 9 pm - midnight each night. Broadband price may increase to $75/mo. (?)
    • Dream Charge: Cheaper rates from 11 pm - 7 am each night. Broadband price may increase to $75/mo. (?)
        I'm currently unsure:
    • what the rates are for Dream Charge. Their website doesn't list them at all.
    • if me switching from my All Day Economy to Low User, Good Nights, or Dream Charge will result in me losing my Broadband bundle special pricing of $70/mo. It may go up to $75/mo. 
    • if changing pricing plans will cost anything. I read somewhere that it will cost $27.
    • if there is a 'metering change.' Of so, it will cost $200. 
    • if connecting a Smart Meter will cost anything (required for Good Nights and Dream Charge plans) - I read it was $27 for a remote connection somewhere, but I'm unsure if this is already connected or not.
    • if the Low User plan comes with any fixed-term contract obligations
    • if I can combine Low User and e.g. Good Nights into the same plan
    • if the Low User plan will continue to be a good deal. NZ is doing away with Low User plans over the next few years, and while it currently looks like it would save me money, in the very near future it likely won't
    • what our usage is throughout the day/night.

  • Nova Multisaver Fibre 300 + Power - Low User
    • Broadband is $69/mo.
    • Fixed daily charge: 90 cents/day
    • Variable charge: 24.044 cents/kWh
    • EA levy: 0.19 cents/kWh
    • Under this plan my last bill would have been $146.22, and my broadband would have been ~$1 cheaper.

  • Electric Kiwi Sweet Fibre 300 Power Bundle - MoveMaster Low User
    • Two months of broadband free, then $79.50/mo ($66.25/mo over the first year)
    • Hour of Power where 1 hour of off peak electricity is free
    • MoveMaster:
      • Fixed daily cost of 30 cents/day
      • Peak hours of 7 - 9 am and 5 - 9 pm: 0.3830/kWh
      • off peak shoulder hours of 9 am - 5 pm; 9 - 11 pm: 0.2681/kWh
      • off peak night hours of 11 pm - 7 am: 0.1915/kWh
      • EA Levy : ?? (assumed the highest rate I've seen - 0.19 cents/kWh)
      • Plus GST (15%)
      • I cannot calculate exactly how much my last bill would have cost because I have no data about how our usage changes throughout the day/night, however, they estimate that I'd save around $280 in electricity costs during the year. 
      • My Fixed daily cost in my last bill would have decreased from $57.62 to $8.70, which is a huge savings altogether. 
      • If I assumed ALL of my energy usage took place during the peak hours, my variable costs in my last bill would actually increase to $194.58. If I assumed it took place in off peak shoulder hours, my bill would decrease to $139.48; If in off peak night hours, $102.75. The real cost is likely somewhere in the middle there. This also doesn't factor in the Hour of Power which would make any electricity usage in a certain off peak hour free.

Overall Comparisons

Here is how all the prices (that I can calculate right now) stack up:


Clearly I should be able to get a better deal if I switch to Low User status, no matter which company I go with. However, as stated above, I don't want to have to switch companies if I don't absolutely have to. 

Therefore, I'm going to strike Nova off of the list completely - it looks like I can get as good of a rate as they offer from Contact (my current company) if I switch to a Low User status, meaning even if I switched to their company, I wouldn't save much over what I can get right now by not switching. 

I really like everything I read about Electric Kiwi. Their whole ethos is fantastic. If I am going to switch to anyone, I'm going to switch to them.

Next Steps

Given all of the above, I think the next steps are to:

  1. Track my energy usage throughout the day for two weeks using the Contact Energy app (10 June update: this is in progress)
    • Calculate averages of energy used per hour to be able to properly estimate the cost of plans with variable prices depending on the time of day.
    • Ask if my flatmate would be amenable to switching the times we use the hot water heater, dishwasher, clothes washer and dryer.

  2. Call Contact and get answers to my questions, above. (10 June update: I've written to them using FB messenger because their customer service doesn't offer a way to call and speak to them directly. I've let them know I am seriously consider switching and asked all of my questions. We'll see how long it takes them to get back to me. In the meantime, I'm tracking my electricity usage!).

  3. Switch to a better plan, whether that is at Contact or elsewhere. Depending on what I find during my investigation in #1 and the answers I get in #2, I'm leaning to either Contact Low User + (Good Nights or Dream Charge) OR switching to Electric Kiwi's Low Usage MaxMover plan with Broadband.


Once I've done my tracking, I'll create a post describing the trends, and once I call Contact I'll post a summary of their answers here. And then of course I'll post my decision.

No comments: