Hmmm, what's this now? There is a lot of chatter about some sort of manifesto. What could cause such controversy in the PF world? THIS I have to check out!
(tries to read the Alt FI Manifesto*) Oh...kay...?
(finds no real intro, just a straight dive into nonsense words) WHAT EVEN IS THIS HORRIBLE WRITING
(scrolls to see if it gets better) OH GOD IT'S SO LONG AND THERE ARE NO REAL POINTS OR FACTS HERE
(it still doesn't make any sense) WAIT, EW, YEAH, THIS ISN'T NEW, IT'S JUST POLITICS
(reads something) GASP! A MIDDLE AGED WHITE HETEROSEXUAL MALE WROTE THIS? SUR-EFFING-PRISE
(starts skipping around the text for some semblance of meaning or personal finance content) I'M TOTALLY LOST, WHAT ARE YOUR EFFING POINTS, WHERE IS THE PF, I JUST SEE SELFISHNESS AND IGNORANCE AND HORRIBLE ARGUMENTS TO PERPETUATE CLASSISM, RACISM, AND SEXISM
(at so many points) OH. HELL. NO. *fury flare ups*
(gets to end) THIS IS NOT PF AND THERE WAS NEVER A POINT (except maybe to rile up people to drive traffic to sell tshirts and a book, as this post points out, s/o to Revanche for the link!
That was basically my thought progression from finding out that the Alt FI Manifesto was a thing (from Revanche's links) and then finding it and reading it. Well, I read as much as I could. It sounded mostly like utter nonsense to me. And there are so many awful bits that have clearly been repeated from the same bots that like to troll people on Twitter, right down to using SJW as a slur/insult.
I'm pretty disappointed that I gave it a click and that someone like that is out there in the personal finance community. I'm also surprised (I really shouldn't be) that so many agreed and offered support for what was written in the comments!
Sigh.
PF has always been a 'safe' community for me. I mean, surely there are PF gurus and bloggers who are racist and sexist while living their lives off line. Dave Ramsey has been slammed for being a terrible boss and bully, for example. The exalted Warren Buffett is casually sexist on the reg. As for the smaller potatoes in the mix, like other bloggers, I haven't always agreed with everyone's views (and vice versa), of course, but those discussions have been open minded and well mannered and not clearly manipulative. But I guess it was only a matter of time before PF was infiltrated by the nonsense pervading the political sphere as of late, and before the same base tactics used to get attention by '45' and his ilk were used by a blogger trying to do the same thing.
It makes me physically ill.
Money is, of course, political. I get that. But this feels and is different. Dangerous-different. These views? They kill and hurt people. They marginalize. They minimize suffering and life's inherent unfairnesses. And just like in the real world, they have NO PLACE in my community.
*the link above is an archived version of the original article and DOES NOT give the offending blog traffic.
2 comments:
I'm sorry you read it. It's utter garbage and it was really disappointing to see how many people agreed wholeheartedly with it. :(
Totally--that was the thing that upset me the most. It's bad enough if it is just one nutter spouting nonsense, but all the comments in support...! I was bewildered. NEVER READ THE COMMENTS.
At least now we know who not to give clicks to. :/
Post a Comment