I decided to look in a little more detail at my budget to see what I could figure out. It's especially good timing because I just got a raise at work. It's time to revise my budget! :)
Here is how I say my values stack up:
- Personal Health: mental, physical (technically includes Home Comforts & Good Food)
- Fulfilling my purpose in Life/Passion (which happens to be my Career. If I can't do this, my personal health is at risk, so this goes before friends/family, sadly.)
- Friends/Family
- Security/Retirement
- Travel/Experiences
- Giving Back
And this is my spending:
Income (typical month with 2 paychecks & 4 weekly carpark rental payments):
2 x $881.28 for part time project management job
2 x $449.30 for PhD
4 x $65 for garage rent
Total: $2,921.16
New Budget (after raise; average month):
Rent: $880 ($220 per week)
Groceries: $450 (this was increased)
Internet: $26.33
Electricity: $50 (average over the year)
Eating Out: $150 (this was increased)
Charity: $50 (this was increased)
Cell phone: $40 (Skype subscription + $16/month cell phone pre-pay plan)
Medical: $75 (this was increased)
Misc: $700
Savings: $500
When I looked at it in more detail, I could make out a few value categories:
Home Comforts: Rent, Electricity
Friends/Family: Cell phone (plus some Misc)
Entertainment: Internet (plus some Misc)
Good Food: Groceries, Eating Out
Health: Medical (plus some Misc for exercise)
Giving Back: Charity
Security/Retirement: Savings
Travel: Savings
The breakdown, by percentage:
Home Comforts: 32%
Entertainment: 1%
Health: 3%
Giving Back: 2%
Security/Retirement: 8% (plus 8% taken out of every paycheck, which isn't shown here)
Travel: 9%
Friends/Family 1%
Good Food: 20%
Other: 24%
SUMMARY
Problems
There are a few problems with this exercise. One is that when you live in a HCOLA and don't make a lot of money, your budget skews heavily towards things like food, rent, utilities, and basic household items. Those need to be taken out of the equation to adequately figure out values from your budget. Also, the things I value don't usually cost a lot of money! For example, I spend most of my time with friends and family playing boardgames, watching TV shows or movies on our couches, cooking dinner together, just chatting or texting over the phone, or going for walks. The last gift I gave was my absolute favourite gift I've ever given someone (a personalised, handcrafted Cards Against Humanity card deck), and it cost $0. So a small amount spent on friends or family is not necessarily reflective of how much I value them. Example #2: Giving back doesn't have to cost money either. I'm donating my hair this year...this also costs me close to $0. A low charity donation for the year doesn't mean that I'm not giving back. Nevertheless, it was a useful exercise.
Discussion
OK, firstly, I need to take out Rent/Utilities and Groceries to some degree, due to the HCOLA issue mentioned earlier. Secondly, 'Other' is such a broad category. I'm not sure how to quantify them, though, so I'm just going to leave them as-is.
Spending by Ranking:
- Home Comforts (32%)
- Other (24%)
- Food (20%)
- Security/Retirement: (16+%; $250 or more per month PLUS 8% of every paycheck)
- Travel (9%)
- Health (3%)
- Giving Back (2%)
- Friends/Family -- Entertainment tied (1%)
- Personal Health: mental, physical (technically includes Home Comforts & Good Food)
- Fulfilling my purpose in Life/Passion
- Friends/Family
- Security/Retirement
- Travel/Experiences
- Giving Back
I found this exercise really interesting but I don't think my spending ultimately reflects how I live my life or what I value that well, mostly because the things I value most can be done very cheaply or for free! In the end, this exercise is most useful for people who maybe spend a ton of money on stuff that they don't cherish or value and need to change that to feel more fulfilled and streamline their budget. For those of us who have figured that out already, or aren't super passionate about clothes, cars, things, etc., it is a bit more tricky to say that our spending adequately reflects our values!
I think I am going to do another post on my time spending vs values. Maybe that one will be more accurate and a more useful exercise for me at this point in my life?
2 comments:
Yeah if I was still renting my budget would certainly NOT reflect my values! You are so right about COL skewing.
It is a problem!! :)
Post a Comment