Friday, March 18, 2016

A Personal Rant about Sexual Harassment in Academia

This NYT article really hit home. There is more than one huge elephant in the academia room, but one in particular has caught my ire as of late. Sexual harassment is rife everywhere, but the article focuses on the topic as found in the fields that particularly lack women: STEM.

I happen to be in one of those STEM fields.

I happen to have seen, first-hand, how gross it can get.

Some of the comments on the article are awful, and very much the reaction we get when we complain: What's the big deal? Can't a guy express his interest in a girl anymore? Why doesn't she just say no and be done with it? These questions highlight how little these commenters know about how it feels to be on the receiving end of unwanted attention in the workplace, and the consequences for rejecting that attention. In fact, those questions and statements are SO ignorant that they actually make the commenters disqualified from having an opinion on the subject at all. It is clear: they just don't get it. It is written all over their face and words.

I've always been lucky that my early educational experience was so easy in this regard. I was in the top STEM classes in high school, and didn't see a huge difference in the number of girls vs boys in the classroom. I probably had more female STEM teachers than men, and they all were incredibly supportive of my interest in STEM. My family always taught me that girls can do anything boys can, and my dad and grandma taught me to throw, shoot, catch, fish, hunt, boat, fix stuff, identify tools, and climb trees like all kids should, regardless of their gender.

In college, men definitely dominated in the classroom teaching roles, but, other than computer science and engineering, my classes were composed of equal parts men and women. And I never felt like my difficulties in certain areas or subject matter was a result of me being female. TAs nor professors ever treated me any differently, that I could tell.

In grad school, I (again) had more male professors than female, but the women in my program (PhD and Master's) outnumbered the men easily. My professors were 100% wonderful and never ever EVER made me feel uncomfortable or called attention to the fact that I was female. This was despite the fact that we all hung out outside of the classroom constantly, with a LOT of drinking involved. The professors came to our birthday parties and house parties, and invited us to theirs without incident. We spent weeks to months in the field alone with professors in some cases. And I, nor any of my friends that I know of, never felt different from the guys doing the same work. There was a strong camaraderie between the student group, and likewise between the students and faculty. We were all on the same team, and it felt like it. I never heard of students sleeping with their professors. This was even though there was plenty of fraternizing amongst the grad students (I myself had a BF who was a PhD while I was a Master's student--in the US the system is much more equal between the two degrees), and there was one(!) instance where a PhD student had a relationship with a post-doc, but he wasn't on her supervisory team, and was in a slightly different field. The upset with that came when she seemed to get papers written quicker than some people thought she should have, given her apparent knowledge and skill level. I don't really consider this the same thing as what the article is talking about. At the time, I wasn't even aware that I should be aware of this kind of thing.

Given my resultant luxury of obliviousness and lack of experience, the fact that major sexual harassment is rife in my current workplace and program snuck up on me. I never attributed certain behaviours to the culture of acceptance around harassing women--I just thought certain people were bad eggs, and avoided them. Also, I have a very strong female mentor in my boss, and she has always supported me. This support has allowed me to continue to blissfully ignore some of the more minor (but telling) incidences.

But things are getting out of controlnow. There are rumours or specific known incidences (see below for a few anecdotes...many) about every single male in the most senior professor positions in my work place. They ALL have a reputation for sexual harassment, sleeping with their students, and/or stealing data from and treating their female students very differently than their male students. Shenanigans!!! Of course, aside from that, there are the more subtle looks/flirtiness/etc. that you feel but cannot describe well with words other than 'Ew. That felt wrong.' This happens too much, as do things like the following anecdotes:
  1. The head of my school has a widely known mistress within the same department. He doesn't make a secret out of it. Regardless of his marital situation, what message does this send to his female students? This is actually the most benign example I have for you, as it only involves a faculty power differential, rather than student-faculty.
  2. My (female) intern found a drawing of a penis on my whiteboard on my door one day. It happened to be the day after I had gotten a significant media article published on my project. It was a professor that did the drawing--he is known to do these things and one of the other students saw him messing about around my door that morning. I assume it was because his work had gotten ignored in the article (he only contributed a tiny portion to the research), a fact that was 100% out of my control. I confronted him about this once I heard it was him, to ask if he was upset about something and felt he needed to do that, and he denied doing it and said I was being silly for asking, he didn't care about that stupid article! I still feel so awful that my intern had to find it. What does this say to her? Accomplish something great, and you will be punished and put in your place, unless a man is standing beside you to take some of the credit.
  3. That same professor only takes female students. He makes snarky comments about their appearance constantly, puts them down, and openly admits he chooses female students because they are easier to control. One of his students told me that she knows she has to put on a skirt in order to get him to say yes to any request she has. He constantly favours the cute, blonde females in his classes, giving them answers and hints about the exams. Lore has it he once took a picture up one of his students' skirts when alone with her. On top of that, he regularly steals his students' data and publishes it himself. I could go on and on. His students (and female faculty colleagues!) have complained about him but still the administration does nothing. He got a warning once to be on better behaviour, but has a new female student starting soon. I have no use for him and avoid him like the plague, EVEN THOUGH he is very knowledgeable in my field and it would be wonderful to have his feedback on my work. Nope. NEVER.
  4. The head of my department famously got seriously reprimanded for sleeping with his female student and impregnating her at another university--basically banned from having students ever again, which pretty much scuppers his career. He looked for jobs elsewhere and was immediately rewarded with a promotion and head research position in my University. No problemo. He is absolutely a big dog in the field and highly respected, brings in a lot of money and publishes a lot. It is clear what hiring teams prioritise. But again, WHAT DOES THIS SAY TO THE FEMALES HE TEACHES AND SUPERVISES? We do not matter.
  5.  Another professor once told his grad student to get close to me and get the dirt on me because I am 'an enigma.' The request and interest was clearly sexual in nature, according to the student (who told me about it a long time afterwards). He had just told her all about how he left his wife and had marital problems, slept with his student, and only went back to her because he missed his kids.
  6. At a large research meeting that I single-handedly organised, chaired, and presented at, I was pointedly allowed to overhear that this same prof found it easier to pay attention to me during the meeting because I was a "pretty girl in a dress." I didn't realise what was happening as it was happening (I was running around like a headless chicken), but later it dawned on me, and I felt angry, cheated, and violated. I was so proud that I pulled that meeting off successfully, and he reduced that accomplishment (a career first) to a successful wardrobe choice. Also at that meeting, I tried to keep him to time during his presentation so people could go to lunch and he said to me, in front of everyone, "I don't care--I'm finishing my presentation. Sit down." I did not know how to handle such disrespect in the moment! But later I had lots of choice words and things I wished I would have said in response, of course. It was humiliating. Would he have done that to a male colleague?
  7. I have to send mass emails out as a part of my job, and he is one of the recipients. He has started sending replies back to just me, snarkily putting other students down. This started before this article came out. I went to my supervisor to complain about it as I was unsure of what to do as I found it inappropriate, and she said that my response to ignore it was the correct one. No poking the hornet's nest, for fear of retribution. He has already done some really shady stuff, encroaching on my PhD research topic and wriggling his way in on one of my projects. No telling what havoc he'd wreak on my career if I stood up to him the way I want to. He exudes schmooziness with the people in charge that should do something about him, and sleaze to the ones who have no power. He keeps asking when he can see me drunk. I refuse to be alone with him in any capacity, and restrict my interactions with him to work-only and business topics. I just refuse to engage in any other way. I've even stopped going to the Friday drinks sessions my department has because I do not want to give him any chances to be inappropriate. And who does that isolation hurt more? Me or him?
 And therein lies the problem. We are damned if we do, and damned if we don't.

And what does this say to the younger, early career men who want to advance to their positions? That this is OK, nay, expected behaviour in order to be successful. The fact that these folks get where they are without repercussion is mind boggling and sets up a nasty precedent.

Of course, sometimes the student/female is a willing participant and maybe even the instigator. Still, where is the backbone from the profs to not cross the line when they're the ones in a position of power?? And, if we look at this statistically, which group is more likely to have instigated these relationships? My bet is NOT on the students. I'm guessing the behaviour by the prof in the beginning is the same, whether it leads to a harassment case or a female student that is willing to encourage or engage in further activity. And that behaviour is what I have major problems with.

I am so ANGRY about all of this. It does NOT have to be this way--my earlier experiences testify to that. I am so fed up at having to hear about this and deal with it and walk this fine line between female and accomplished STEMmer. Can't I just do my job well?!