So, yes, you can negotiate your way through your PhD. I even believe that you should, and any potential supervisor should be open to your ideas and shaping your project to meet your goals. At the very least, there should be wiggle room to compromise.
Here's why:
- Only you know exactly what you want to get out of the process in the end. Is it a job at 'X' company? An academic career? Twelve publications? A mental breakdown* (*I've heard that that comes free with purchase)? This is 3 to 5+ years of your life. Don't waste the opportunity to get your voice heard early.
- Only you know how much you'll need to live off of. Work that out and figure backwards. Will you HAVE to work the max amount of hours allowed to take care of Millie your dog and Minerva your aunt?
- Your advisors will hopefully do what they can to help you, but they want something from you, too, and will naturally make that a priority if you don't say anything about what your priorities are. Stick up for yourself!
- The number one complaint I hear from PhD student friends is that they regret not speaking up in the beginning to make their interests and goals clear.
So recently I had the Big Meeting. The one where I met with my potential PhD supervisors and negotiated. I asked for everything I wanted to get from the experience. It went surprisingly well thanks to my spontaneously-invented-five-prong strategy:
- I have done my homework. I know EXACTLY the kind of job I want at the end. I have looked at the job boards for years and copied the descriptions and requirements into one document. I handed these to my potential supervisors.
- I have watched friends go through their PhDs since 2000, and I know how many ways things can go wrong. I have taken mental notes on what caused the problems, and tried to address them in what I secretly called my List of Demands. I also talked to almost everyone I know that had been through a PhD to ask them what they would have asked for in the beginning if they could have. I went through each of these in turn in the meeting.
- Go over that list with a trusted mentor. I have two male supervisors and one female. I've worked with the female supervisor for 5 years now; she knows exactly how I work. She is also great at massaging egos and saying the right things to get exactly what she wants. She is a total star, and this is why I flatly refused to do a PhD without her involved. If you can find someone like this, stick with them. I asked to meet with her prior to the Big Meeting to go over what I wanted to say, and to make sure I was not asking for anything that would destroy the opportunity in a fit of entitlement. Even if you will not have an advocate in the Big Meeting, you should definitely talk to another academic who knows how these things usually work and can advise you on how to phrase your demands.
- I approached the problem from a mutually beneficial perspective. People are unsurprisingly flexible if you show them how giving you what you want helps them as well.
- I sometimes felt quite guilty demanding these while so many other people would kill to have this opportunity. Was I overstepping my bounds? How entitled was I to ask for more than I had already been given?! I tried to manage that feeling by going through the reasons I mentioned in the beginning of this post. (I wonder if this is a female thing, particularly because I grew up in the South, where you are taught to be polite and pleasant at all times, go out of your way to make others comfortable, and generally people please.)
Want to know my list and their responses?
- Since I want to move back to the US, and I know exactly where I want to work, I asked for time at various US institutions to start to make connections. I mentioned that this kind of collaboration looks fantastic to the funders and is great for the Department's reputation. Response: They agreed whole-heartedly and we wrote some ideas about where to send me. (This also allows me to get some of my flight costs to visit home covered!)
- I asked to go to international conferences once every 1.5 years. I showed them how wonderfully motivating, helpful, and successful my recent conference experiences had been to my research thus far. Response: They agreed as long as I was producing original work to present at each conference. This is fair.
- I want to take classes, and have a special seminar each week to get the background I need to do my project well. Response: They agreed and volunteered to run the seminar.
- I want fieldwork. Response: They agreed and suggested various areas, one area that I've always wanted to go to NZ but haven't had the chance to yet. If we can tie my research to an international location (which should be do-able), I may get to go to Spain while one of my advisors works there. I also will be going along on most, if not all, of the field trips planned for the classes.
- I want to continue my current job and finish up my current project, slated to end next year. The project will probably continue beyond that time, but I want to make sure it is successful and that all objectives are completed by the official end date. This will take a lot of work in the next year, so I want a 50% work and 50% PhD time commitment to start. Response: OK, no problem, and we will revisit this percentage next year. By that point I should be in a great place to ramp up research anyway, and this will give me time to assimilate to the new schedule and budget. I tentatively agreed to 25/75.
- I want to apply to a prestigious fellowship in the US. Response: We will give you that time to go if you get the fellowship.
- I want weekly meetings with my supervisor, at least for the first year and at any time I'm having difficulties. Response: Great, that works.
- I want to continue the outreach and a few other aspects of my current work that will allow me to apply what I learn beyond the hard science. This will be done through my 50% work, not the PhD, but it is important to me that I see the implications and impact of my research directly. Response: No problem.
- I do not want to be collecting data until the end. I want a final completion date so I have time to start writing up my dissertation without constantly rewriting it to figure out new data implications. Response: This is negotiable and depends on progress as it is a part-time degree.
- I don't want to move offices again. My average is once per year now. Ridiculous. Response: Fine for now; if more grad students come and it makes sense for all of us to be in the same office (because we'll be studying the same thing), it will be revisited.
- I want registration fees for professional societies paid for. Response: OK up to a certain number, to be determined on a case to case basis, and only for organisations deemed most relevant to my research.
- I want to have a monthly development meeting for all PhDs, post-docs, and other interested faculty to discuss issues, ideas, and techniques regarding professional skills we need, such as handling large amounts of data, presenting at conferences, and writing journal articles. Response: Great idea, you organise it and we will take turns talking about various topics and teaching others strategies we've learned over our careers.
While I kind of approached it like a peace treaty meeting between two warring factions, the experience showed me that my potential supervisors are highly adaptable to my suggestions, want to listen, and are actually on my side. I hope that they garnered some respect for me in the process; I certainly am proud that I brought up these nagging issues! Personally, I think that negotiating is a strong way to start off a PhD.
3 comments:
I am super super impressed. You knew exactly what you wanted, phrased it to show the benefits to them, and got what you wanted.
I agree with ee,I'm really impressed with your knowing what you want!
Thanks ladies!
It was nerve wracking but I knew I had to do it.
Post a Comment