Monday, March 24, 2008

Pay Day Loans Worsen the Housing Crisis

According to this article, many people strapped for cash due to their mortgage resets are turning to pay-day loans, digging their financial hole even deeper. These homeowners-for-now (as I've dubbed them) are ruining their futures by futilely grasping at any straw out there, and not facing facts--they cannot afford their house. I really think we need to reduce the options out there that they have for keeping their house even longer...nip this in the bud!

The crisis is only going to continue to get worse as people get in more and more trouble and debt, and if easy cash is available. People will take advantage of every easy-access to cash out there that the government will allow. If financial education isn't government mandated in schools and beyond, the government should not allow practices that prey on its citizens. Simple as that. It ISN'T the government's respoonsibility to teach good financial practices--but obviously we've seen what happens when they don't, and when they simultaneously allow businesses that prey on the needy.

I feel bad for those people that were duped into believing that the housing market would continue to rise, but this is rediculous. It needs to END.

The government should ban payday and subprime loans, and predatory lending practices--absolutely. That's how this mess started. As for the government handouts--I'm on the fence about whether the government should help out the people who are losing their houses. The businesses should suffer the consequences for their practices--with no government help. As for the people, I feel bad for them, but on the same token, there are people out there who waited, and are waiting, to buy because they knew it was smarter to buy with a downpayment. So should they get a bailout? My gut feeling, based on fairness, says no. I don't think they should keep their houses. I do think there should be an easy out clause for the people, something that makes the banks suffer for lending money to undeserving people.

The good news is that states are starting to take notice of this trend and place caps on the interest rates on these horrible businesses that take advantage of desperate homeowners. The next step is to regulate the lending that takes place over the internet.

6 comments:

Leslie said...

It sucks but I tend to agree with you - the government shouldn't provide a bailout.

The percentage of people who are getting their house foreclosed or really seriously suffering is tiny compared to the overall population. (It's still a lot of people just due to the size of the US as a whole) but a government bailout isn't fair to the guy who was ripped off last year by the same practices and who lost his house.

These people really cannot afford the homes they are in and should try to get out from under them as fast as possible.

I think that financial education should be a part of every high school curriculum. It won't fix everything, but it will get a lot more people informed and educated about money.

I am curious about why you are on the fence about bailouts, what would be your reasons for (maybe) supporting them?

Sense said...

the only reason I would support bailouts (for homeowners ONLY) is because I think alot of people that normally would never be able to own a home saw this as their one chance--and if the market had kept home values up, they could've refinanced for a fixed rate, and they'd be fine right now. I think alot of people were lied to and taken advantage of, and I'm sympathetic to their situation.

Anonymous said...

I think all 3 of you are full of dog squeeze. It's time for "adults" to act that way and live with the consequences of their actions. Perhaps we can fault government schools that these "poor" borrowers can't read the loan documents they signed. As for payday lending..what's the APR on an nsf check? Think people! We don't need the government to take care of us from womb to tomb!

Anonymous said...

Limiting access to credit will not eliminate the housing crisis, or any other crisis for that matter. People should have the right to choose whether they want to borrow money, and lenders should have the right to choose whether they want to lend the money. If the lender makes a bad loan, then the lender loses the money. Reducing the costs of default will incent the lenders to make sound loans.

Eliminating credit options will raise the cost of credit for all. Government should ensure that business has a fair and transparent market to operate in, and then let the market work.

Anonymous said...

While it’s in fashion to blame payday loans for all of society’s problems there’s simply no evidence connecting them with the housing crisis.

Payday loans are small dollar short-term loans which average $300 and have a flat fee of $15 to $17 per $100 borrowed. Customers use these loans to avoid costly penalties on bounced checks, late bill payment fees or overdraft protection.

When the average credit card debt is more than $10,000 and the average monthly car payment is $479 it is inconceivable to place blame on a $300 loan. In fact, the exact opposite may be true as research by Adair Morse of the University of Chicago shows. Her findings indicate that the existence of payday lenders significantly offset the increase in foreclosures in times of natural (and potentially personal) disaster.

As a representative of the payday lending industry, I believe consumers should have the freedom to choose between credit options. For many working Americans with unexpected expenses payday loans are an option preferable to alternatives. Consumers don’t benefit when financial options are taken away and competition in credit market is significantly restricted.

Unknown said...

Nice segway! Houses are going into foreclosure so we need to ban payday loans! Awesome, makes no sense, but awesome! Houses are hundreds of thousands of dollars, payday loans are $500 at the most. How are these two things even in the same category? Because they are loans? Getting foreclosed on, and not being able to pay your payday loan, are two completely different things. We need to stop blaming the payday lenders for everyone else's irresponsibility! If I borrow 100 bucks from a friend, and am not able to pay it back, I don't blame my friend for lending me the money! That is just stupid. So why are we blaming our payday lender friends for providing a great service? In a recent article by ex senator and presidential candidate George McGovern, he says, "[p]ayday lending bans simply push low-income borrowers into less pleasant options, including increased rates of bankruptcy," Mr. McGovern rightly poses the question: "Why do we think we are helping adult consumers by taking away their options?"
Later in the article, he says, "[t]he nature of freedom of choice is that some people will misuse their responsibility and hurt themselves in the process. We should do our best to educate them, but without diminishing choice for everyone else."
This is how we need to look at this topic. Leave the payday loan stores alone and look for other options. Instead of taking away payday lenders, beat them at their own game by giving consumers even more alternatives!